Paper Rights Management

Analog hole, Arbitrary, Blog, Bureaucracy, Business model, Consumer rights, Copyright, Design with Intent, Do artifacts have politics?, Embedding code, Erosion of liberty, Intellectual property, Law, Nonsense, Restriction, Textbooks, User experience

Springer delivery note
Springer delivery note
This delivery note from Springer informs me that the book I’ve bought “must not be resold”. Good luck with that. So have I bought it or not? Or have I bought a licence to read it? What if I give it away?
Many companies would love to be able to control what users can do with things they buy, or with information after someone’s learned it. We know that, and we know that, fundamentally, it’s not going to work. You can try and shape behaviour, to guide users into helping themselves, but nonsense such “end-user licence agreements” for books has no mechanism of enforcement, and offers no benefit to the reader if he/she obeys it anyway.
How valid, legally, are any of these “post-purchase conditions”, anyway? Surely the first-sale doctrine or its equivalents allow users to re-sell items they buy with impunity?


Comments are closed.